Skip to content
GUIDEDeep dive

Repair or Replace: Costs and the 30% Rule

Above ~30% of replacement cost or near end of life, replacement usually wins.

Updated 2026-11-10 · Formula checked

Compare

Repair/replace.

Material/lifespan.

30% rule.

Conditions

Leaks/structure.

Partial/overlay.

Warranty/permits.

FAQ

What is the 30% rule?

When repair nears 30% of replacement, replace.

Can I overlay?

Depends on code/structure/region.

Sources

Insurance Claims and Permit ChecklistRead guide

Check your use case first

Five things to check before ordering

How to compare specs

When not to buy

Budget and alternatives

Common mistakes

KEEP READING

Keep reading

Read in order, or jump to another guide on the same topic.

All guides →

None

Top picks

Angi

Contractors/reviews

Check price
HomeAdvisor

Quotes/leads

Check price
GAF

Materials/warranty

Check price

Affiliate disclosure: this page may contain affiliate links and we may earn a commission.

Sources